Vale Earnings Disappoint With Rising Costs Adding to Iron Rout

Vale SA reported lower-than-expected earnings as the world’s No. 2 iron-ore producer grappled with a pullback in prices of the steelmaking ingredient at a time of rising energy and transport costs.

Adjusted earnings before items came in at $6.94 billion in the third quarter, the Rio de Janeiro-based company reported Thursday. That beat the year-ago result but was down from the second quarter and trailed the $8.83 billion average estimate.

After recovering economies sent prices and profits surging earlier this year, iron ore miners are coming back down to earth. Futures are down about 50% since mid-July as China curbs steel output to contain pollution and power use while costs are rising along with freight and bunker oil prices. Vale is starting to trim supply of lower-quality ores to defend margins.

Still, the average third-quarter iron ore price stayed above year-ago levels, helping push up net income by 34% to $3.89 billion. Separately, Vale announced a new program to buy back as many as 200 million shares, which at current prices would be worth $2.6 billion. That follows the repurchase of almost all shares in a 270 million program. 

Vale’s Sao Paulo shares have fallen 16% this year in line with the average among peers. Its New York-listed shares were little changed after the close of trading Thursday.

Vale and peers Rio Tinto Group and BHP Group were cut to hold from buy at Jefferies due to “near-term downside risk to iron ore and to consensus forecasts, declining capital returns, accelerating cost pressures, and increased operating risk.”

While Vale produced more than analysts expected last quarter as part of an ongoing recovery from a 2019 tailings dam disaster, sales lagged production. Analysts will be looking out for more details on the “value-over-volume” strategy on calls with analysts Friday.